About this season
Two investigators re-examine controversial murder cases to help the desperate families of those convicted decide if it's time to appeal... or accept the guilty verdict once and for all.
Episodes (10)
1. A Murder in Cave Creek
Aired 12 July 2021 • 42 min
Justin Lunsford, convicted of murdering a popular bartender after a night of sex and drugs, insists he’s innocent; his brother and wife are asking Chris and Fatima to join their fight to free Justin.
2. My Best Friend's Murder
Aired 19 July 2021 • 42 min
A man takes the fall for his best friend's murder in Ogema, Minnesota.
3. Deadhead
Aired 26 July 2021 • 42 min
Bruce Walton is in prison, convicted of the fatal stabbing of his lifelong friend Roy Fuller; Bruce's sisters are convinced he is innocent, and they are hoping Chris and Fatima will join them in their fight to free Bruce.
4. For Her Love
Aired 2 August 2021 • 42 min
War veteran Tim Wright is in prison for killing his girlfriend's ex, but his family is convinced he is innocent. Now they've reached out to Chris Anderson and Fatima Silva, hoping they will join their fight.
5. The Cult of David
Aired 9 August 2021 • 43 min
Yvonne Layne, a beautiful mother of five, dies due to a murder plot masterminded by her ex, David Thorne, and carried out by his friend. Both men are convicted, but David’s family refuses to accept the verdict and wants Chris and Fatima to help.
6. Trapped in the Middle
Aired 16 August 2021 • 43 min
A woman calls for Chris and Fatima to decide whether they think her husband is innocent.
7. Hypnotized
Aired 23 August 2021 • 42 min
Sisters fight for a man convicted of a 1995 gang-related hit as a teen.
8. To Dye For
Aired 30 August 2021 • 42 min
A jury convicts a woman for the triple murder of an Ohio family.
9. State of Denial
Aired 13 September 2021 • 43 min
A family fears their son is wrongly serving a life sentence for murder.
10. A $25,000 Performance
Aired 20 September 2021 • 43 min
A self-admitted con man insists he's not a murderer.