About this season
Hosted by Alan Cumming, a shocking murder rocks a tight-knit community to its core. But what if the crime wasn't committed by a stranger or outsider? What if this killer is part of the community itself?
Episodes (7)
1. Murder on Main Street
Aired 17 May 2026 • 42 min
With just over one hundred residents, the farming village of Colon, Nebraska is built on trust; when county treasurer Sharron Erickson is found murdered in her town garage, Main Street becomes a crime scene where no one can trust their neighbor.
2. Fatal Friend Group
Aired 24 May 2026 • 44 min
When 20-year-old Anna Cardwell is found shot to death in her rural Alabama home, her close circle of friends mourn in disbelief. But soon speculation begins to swirl that one of their own is not who they seem.
3. Death in the Dorms
Aired 31 May 2026 • 43 min
A university for the deaf serves as a haven for its students. But when a freshman is brutally murdered in his dorm, the student body is plunged into terror. When it happens again, investigators race to uncover a connection and stop a serial killer.
4. Murder in the Gallery
Aired 7 June 2026 • 44 min
When a Sarasota, Florida gallery proprietor is found murdered and posed like a grisly sculpture, everyone in the renowned art community fears for their lives wondering if it could be one of their own artists putting evil on display.
5. Betrayal in Blue
Aired 14 June 2026 • 42 min
When sheriff-elect Derwin Brown is gunned down just days before taking office, investigators uncover a tangled web of secrets - forcing them to confront the chilling possibility that the killer may be hiding within law enforcement's own ranks.
6. In the Shadow of the Steeple
Aired 21 June 2026 • 42 min
A shocking murder shatters a tight-knit community; but the killer isn't an outsider-it's one of their own; as suspicion spreads and secrets unravel, everyone is a suspect.
7. Vanishing in the Lab
Aired 28 June 2026 • 43 min
A shocking murder shatters a tight-knit community; but the killer isn't an outsider-it's one of their own; as suspicion spreads and secrets unravel, everyone is a suspect.