The Real Murders on Elm Street — Season 2
Sometimes, the scariest nightmares are real.
About this season
Explore true stories of real murders on Elm Streets across the county — proving that horror happens everywhere, things do go bump in the night, and no one is safe.
Episodes (6)
1. Someone's Watching Her
7.0Aired 1 October 2025 • 44 min
When 20-year-old Cindy Sumner vanishes in Toledo, Ohio, a cryptic message lures detectives to Elm Street. In the decaying warehouse ruins, they uncover signs of a twisted obsession-and a nightmare that blurs the line between fiction and true evil.
2. Trailing a Killer
7.0Aired 8 October 2025 • 44 min
On New Year's Eve, Tara Gillon's father finds her murdered in their Massachusetts home. No suspect; few clues. Just one trail of footprints in fresh snow.
3. Mommy's Dead
8.0Aired 15 October 2025 • 42 min
A crew of immigrant gang members stalk Vietnamese families across state lines, leaving horror behind. After one family is killed, police uncover a massacre on Elm Street; one boy survives. Then, a third family massacre occurs; two young boys survive. The killers must be stopped before striking again.
4. Laced With White Powder
7.0Aired 22 October 2025 • 42 min
Three friends arrive for a haircut - only to find their barber dead, his body sprinkled with a mysterious white powder; as police dig in, one clue stands out: he'd just come into money; was it a robbery - or a betrayal by someone he never saw coming?
5. Savage Woods
8.0Aired 29 October 2025 • 42 min
When a hunter discovers bones in the Pennsylvania woods, it looks like a bear attack. However, a chilling confession exposes something far more savage — a violent betrayal by those closest to him, proof that trust can be fatal.
6. Nightmare Before Christmas
7.0Aired 5 November 2025 • 42 min
The day before Christmas Eve, police answer a call to find two women bound and suffocated. No sign of forced entry. They learn the victims owned most of Elm Street and the killer may be closer than anyone dares to imagine.